Reflections on Leadership

Yesterday I posted a blog on whether we should be labelling children or not and it caused a bit of a localised twitterstorm with impassioned views flying back and forth for and against. This has got me thinking about the influence of leadership in a school and how it impacts on behaviour; there is also a direct link to the perceived use of labels.

Over the years I have worked in various schools and encountered a range of leadership styles. These broadly fall (for me) into three categories:
Firstly there are the Dictators, the ‘my way or the highway’ types who rule by fear and use an iron grip to keep behaviour in check (teachers and children!). They are often charismatic, although not in a good way, and are heavily reliant on rigid power-based control systems which are inflexible and mitigate against personal growth and development. They accept children acquire labels along the way but don’t let this interfere with discipline.

Secondly there are the Professors, those with a lot of knowledge about child development and conditions such as ODD, ADHD but not much common sense about how schools work. They talk the talk but cannot walk the walk and in my opinion are the worst of the bunch. Their schools are characterised by organisational chaos and the children don’t THINK they are in charge they KNOW they are in charge! Staff are regularly undermined and the children can be found in the head’s office complaining about their teachers! Professors think we should love children better and we often have the bruises to prove it!

Thirdly there are the Motivators, these get the best out of staff and children, lead by example and have a shrewd understanding of what makes us all tick. We know they are in charge but in a positive way. They never let children use their ‘conditions’ as an excuse for poor behaviour but have time to spare in times of genuine need. Their schools are characterised by a positive, calm ethos which engenders teaching and
learning with clear rules and boundaries; respect for adults and each other is not optional.

So what do I conclude from these reflections? Ultimately, a school is only as good as its leader- sadly my experience of working for a Professor nearly caused me to quit my job and has been a scarring experience! At least dictators keep control ! Fortunately I have worked with some brilliant Motivators including my present HT (thankfully)! In our PRU relationships are key and children know that they are not in charge. Yes there are blips and problems but we work as a team to sort them out.


5 thoughts on “Reflections on Leadership

  1. Very interesting look on leadership. I worked for a head who you describe as a dictator for 4 years and although it was hard work, the leadership style certainly was effective in terms of results; the downside being it was at the expense of staff morale and health.
    I now work for a motivator. Wow… simply, wow!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s